Who Invented the Old Fashioned? The Pendennis Club Story (and the Truth)

If you ask who invented the Old Fashioned, the popular answer is the Pendennis Club in Louisville, Kentucky, sometime in the 1880s, often credited to a bartender named Martin Cuneo or a club member named Colonel James E. Pepper (a bourbon distiller who reportedly carried the recipe to New York). The story is charming and Kentucky bourbon-tourism markets it heavily. The story is also wrong — or, more accurately, it conflates the invention of the Old Fashioned with the popularization of the name "Old Fashioned." The cocktail itself predates Pendennis Club by approximately 75 years.

The actual history is more interesting and a little less neat. The drink we now call an Old Fashioned was first described in print in 1806, the term "Old Fashioned cocktail" emerged decades later as a way to distinguish the original recipe from increasingly elaborate cocktails of the late 1800s, and the Pendennis Club almost certainly did not invent the cocktail — though it likely did help popularize the name. Here's the actual record.

The 1806 Definition

On May 13, 1806, the Hudson, New York newspaper The Balance and Columbian Repository published the first known printed definition of "cocktail." A reader had written in asking what a cocktail actually was, and the editor responded:

"Cocktail is a stimulating liquor, composed of spirits of any kind, sugar, water, and bitters — it is vulgarly called a bittered sling, and is supposed to be an excellent electioneering potion."

That definition — spirit, sugar, water, bitters — is exactly the recipe for what we now call an Old Fashioned. In 1806, this drink was simply called "a cocktail." There was no "Old Fashioned" yet because there was no need to distinguish it from anything else. Cocktail meant this specific four-ingredient construction.

For the broader history, see The History of the Old Fashioned.

How "Cocktail" Became "Old Fashioned"

Through the 1800s, bartenders started adding things — vermouth, curaçao, absinthe, fruit juices, soda. By the 1880s, "cocktail" had broadened to mean any mixed drink. The original four-ingredient construction needed a new name to distinguish it from the elaborate concoctions filling bartenders' guides.

The name "Old-Fashioned" appeared in print in the 1880s as drinkers began asking for "the old-fashioned cocktail" — meaning, the original simple version. The earliest documented use of the term in print is from 1880, in a Chicago newspaper story describing a cocktail order. By the 1890s, "Old Fashioned" was established as a menu item at bars across the country.

The Pendennis Club Story

The Pendennis Club is a private social club in Louisville, Kentucky, founded in 1881. The popular story credits a Pendennis bartender (variously named Martin Cuneo, James Cooke, or simply "an unnamed bartender") with inventing the Old Fashioned in honor of Colonel James E. Pepper, a Kentucky bourbon distiller and Pendennis member. Pepper supposedly liked the cocktail so much that he carried the recipe to the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel bar in New York, where it spread to American cocktail culture nationally.

The story has several problems:

• The cocktail predates the Pendennis Club by 75 years. The 1806 newspaper definition is documented; the Pendennis Club opened in 1881. The recipe wasn't invented at Pendennis — it had existed for generations.
• James E. Pepper's role is poorly documented. No surviving primary source confirms he carried the recipe to the Waldorf-Astoria. The story comes from Pendennis Club lore, not from Pepper's own letters or business records.
• The "named bartender" varies by source. Different versions of the story credit different bartenders, suggesting the actual originator is unknown or that the story was constructed retroactively.
• No 1880s newspaper or trade publication mentions Pendennis as the OF's birthplace. The earliest references to the Pendennis-OF connection appear in the 20th century.

What Pendennis Club almost certainly did: serve a quality version of the Old Fashioned consistently from the 1880s onward, helping popularize the name and the recipe in elite Kentucky social circles. That's a meaningful contribution. It's just not invention.

Colonel James E. Pepper: Real, but Limited Role

James E. Pepper (1850–1906) was a real person — a Kentucky bourbon distiller and the great-grandson of Elijah Pepper, who founded the Old Pepper distillery (still operating). The Pepper family is documented in Kentucky distilling history. James E. Pepper was a member of the Pendennis Club. He did spend time in New York. He did promote his bourbon (Old 1776 / James E. Pepper) heavily.

What's plausible: Pepper used the Old Fashioned as a way to showcase his bourbon at the Waldorf-Astoria and other New York venues, helping spread both the cocktail and his bourbon brand. What's not documented: that he invented the cocktail or that Pendennis was the cocktail's origin point.

The James E. Pepper bourbon brand still exists (relaunched in 2008 by Georgetown Trading Company). They actively reference the Pendennis Club story in their marketing, which is part of why the legend persists.

Why the Pendennis Story Persists

Three reasons:

1. Tourism marketing. Kentucky's bourbon tourism industry — Bourbon Trail, distillery tours, Louisville hotel marketing — benefits from claiming the Old Fashioned as a Kentucky invention. Pendennis Club is a tangible piece of that story.
2. Brand marketing. James E. Pepper bourbon explicitly markets the Pendennis story. So do other Kentucky brands that benefit from the cocktail's association with bourbon.
3. It's a better story than the truth. "An anonymous bartender invented this for a colonel in 1880s Louisville" is more memorable than "the cocktail evolved gradually from a 1806 newspaper definition over decades." Stories beat facts in popular memory.

The Pendennis story isn't fraud — it's marketing built on a kernel of truth (Pendennis did serve Old Fashioneds; Pepper did promote the cocktail). It's just incomplete history.

Other Origin Claims

Various other places have claimed Old Fashioned origin:

• Waldorf-Astoria, New York: Documented as serving Old Fashioneds in the 1890s, but as receiver, not originator. Pepper allegedly introduced it there.
• Wisconsin / Milwaukee: Wisconsin's Old Fashioned culture (brandy-based, with cherries and orange slices muddled in) developed independently from the classic recipe, around the early 1900s. See Brandy Old Fashioned. Wisconsin didn't invent the OF, but it did invent the regional variant.
• New Orleans: The Sazerac Cocktail (rye, Peychaud's bitters, sugar, absinthe rinse) is sometimes cited as a parallel development. New Orleans cocktail history is rich and parallel rather than directly tied. See Old Fashioned vs Sazerac.
• England: Some British cocktail historians point to gin-and-bitters constructions in 18th-century London that predate the 1806 American definition. The category overlap is real but the specific four-ingredient OF formula is American.

The Honest Answer

If someone asks who invented the Old Fashioned, the most accurate answer is:

The Old Fashioned wasn't invented by anyone — it evolved. The four-ingredient cocktail (spirit, sugar, water, bitters) was first defined in print in 1806. As cocktails grew more elaborate through the 1800s, drinkers asking for "the old-fashioned cocktail" — the original simple version — gave the drink its current name in the 1880s. The Pendennis Club in Louisville helped popularize the name and the recipe, but didn't invent it.

If someone wants the more colorful version, the Pendennis Club / James E. Pepper story is fine to tell, with the caveat that it's club lore rather than documented history.

Why Rye, Not Bourbon?

One more bit of historical clarification: the original Old Fashioned was a rye whiskey cocktail, not a bourbon one. American whiskey production in the early 1800s was overwhelmingly rye-based. Bourbon's rise as the dominant American whiskey came later. The Pendennis Club / Kentucky bourbon associations have shifted the modern understanding of the Old Fashioned toward bourbon, but historically the cocktail was rye. For the historical case, see Why Rye Is Traditional for Old Fashioned.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who invented the Old Fashioned cocktail?

No single person. The four-ingredient cocktail (spirit, sugar, water, bitters) was first defined in print in 1806 in a Hudson, New York newspaper. The name "Old Fashioned" emerged in the 1880s to distinguish the original recipe from increasingly elaborate cocktails. The Pendennis Club in Louisville helped popularize it but didn't invent it.

What is the Pendennis Club story?

The popular legend credits a Pendennis Club bartender in 1880s Louisville with inventing the Old Fashioned in honor of Colonel James E. Pepper, who supposedly carried the recipe to New York's Waldorf-Astoria. The story is club lore rather than documented history — the cocktail predates Pendennis by 75 years.

Was the Old Fashioned invented in Kentucky?

The cocktail was not invented in Kentucky. It was first documented in 1806 in a New York newspaper. Kentucky's Pendennis Club popularized the name and recipe in the 1880s, and the Kentucky bourbon industry has since claimed the cocktail as its own — but that's marketing, not invention.

Who was Colonel James E. Pepper?

James E. Pepper (1850–1906) was a Kentucky bourbon distiller, member of the Pendennis Club, and great-grandson of Elijah Pepper, founder of Old Pepper distillery. He's credited with promoting the Old Fashioned at the Waldorf-Astoria in New York, though primary sources don't confirm he invented it.

When was the Old Fashioned first made?

The four-ingredient cocktail (spirit, sugar, water, bitters) is documented from May 13, 1806, in The Balance and Columbian Repository newspaper. That's the earliest known printed reference. The drink itself is likely older but undocumented.

What's the oldest cocktail in the world?

The Old Fashioned (then called simply "cocktail") at 1806 is among the oldest documented cocktails in the modern Western tradition. Older mixed drinks exist (punch from the 1600s, sangaree, sling), but the Old Fashioned-style four-ingredient cocktail is the foundational modern American cocktail.

More Archive: Full History of the Old Fashioned · Why Rye Is Traditional · What Is an Old Fashioned

🗺️

Continue Exploring

The Old Fashioned Corner

Complete map of every Old Fashioned variation, technique, ingredient guide, and comparison — RyeCentral's full editorial library.

→