Penelope Straight Rye Review
Penelope Straight Rye Review
Where to buy Penelope Straight Rye online
Compare current prices for Penelope Straight Rye at ReserveBar and Total Wine & More.
WHERE TO BUY — ONLINE & LOCAL
Quick Facts
Penelope Straight Rye Review: The Short Answer
The RyeCentral Consensus Score for Penelope Straight Rye is 3.3/5.
Penelope Straight Rye is the core rye in Penelope's Classic Series, distilled at Ross & Squibb in Lawrenceburg, Indiana and released in June 2026. It is bottled at 92 proof (46% ABV) from a 93% rye, 7% malted barley mash bill, with no age statement. What defines it is the herbal register: spearmint runs through the nose and palate, with dill on the aroma and a wave of rye spice, citrus and brown sugar behind it. Oak barely registers. It is an approachable, mint-forward rye built for mixing and easy sipping rather than depth. Full tasting notes, prices and comparisons follow below.
Is This For Me?
You want the classic herbal rye register — spearmint, wintergreen and dill — at an everyday price. It is soft at 92 proof, genuinely easy to drink, and the 93% rye mash bill gives it real rye character without sharpness. A strong, cheap mixer.
You want oak, age or weight. Six of nine reviewers found no wood on the palate at all, mouthfeel splits between "thin" and "amazing", and there is no age statement. Reviewers broadly land on competent rather than memorable.
Flavor Profile at a Glance
What It Tastes Like
Nose
Spearmint leads, with clear dill behind it, then rye spice, brown sugar, bright citrus and a touch of ginger.
Palate
Rye spice through the middle, mint running cool alongside it, with citrus, brown sugar, caramel and black pepper.
Finish
Medium — spearmint and wintergreen fading into pepper and lingering rye spice, drying gently at the end.
Best Ways to Enjoy
Manhattan
Where the herbal register earns its keep — the mint and rye spice cut through sweet vermouth cleanly.
Old Fashioned
Brown sugar and caramel are already there, so go light on the syrup and let the spearmint show.
Whiskey Sour
The citrus on the palate — lemon, orange rind — makes this a natural fit. A genuinely good cheap sour.
Neat
Easy at 92 proof, with no burn reported anywhere. Pleasant, though the light body shows most here.
Cocktail Scores
Price & Value
This is the strongest thing about the bottle. A 93% rye mash bill at 92 proof for around $35 is a genuinely competitive everyday price, and nobody reviewing it has complained about value. Reviewers converge on "competent" rather than "memorable" — Breaking Bourbon's summary, that it is "not overly deep and is far from being noteworthy, but the sip it delivers is good enough to please most," is about as representative as a single sentence gets. If you want more oak and weight at a similar price, our Rittenhouse Bottled-in-Bond is the obvious comparison; for more options in this band, see best value rye whiskeys.
Bottle Transparency
- Brand / BottlerPenelope Whiskey — part of the Classic Series, alongside Penelope Kentucky Straight Bourbon
- DistilleryRoss & Squibb Distillery (formerly MGP), Lawrenceburg, Indiana — disclosed by the brand
- Mash Bill93% rye, 7% malted barley — published, and confirmed independently in six of nine reviews
- AgeNo age statement. Several retailers claim "7 to 9 years" — Penelope has never confirmed this and at least one reviewer suspects it is nearer the four-year straight minimum. We treat the retailer claim as unverified.
- Proof92 proof / 46% ABV
- ReleasedJune 2026; current release
Full Review: Penelope Straight Rye
A Bourbon Brand's Rye
Penelope built its name on four-grain bourbon, so a core rye in the Classic Series is a statement of intent rather than a side project. It arrived in June 2026 at 92 proof, sourced from Ross & Squibb in Lawrenceburg — the Indiana distillery behind a great many of the ryes on our shelves — on a 93% rye, 7% malted barley mash bill. At $34.99 it sits directly against the everyday benchmarks.
Aroma & Palate
The defining note is spearmint, and it is not subtle. Five of nine reviewers find mint on the nose and six find it on the palate; one described the first sip as setting off "an earthquake of spearmint with an even bigger aftershock of wintergreen." Behind it sits dill — reported by three independent reviewers, one calling it "heavy" — then rye spice, brown sugar, citrus and a little ginger. The palate keeps the herbal thread going and adds citrus in a candied form: lemon peel, orange rind, lemonade powder. Brown sugar and caramel carry the sweetness, with black pepper at the edges.
Two things are conspicuously missing. Oak barely appears at all — only two of nine reviewers found wood on the palate, which is both the weakest-supported reading on this page and entirely consistent with a young, unaged-stated rye. And nobody reports heat. At 92 proof there is no burn language anywhere in the corpus, which is why our heat score is low despite the proof.
Where The Brand And The Reviewers Disagree
Penelope's own copy promises "bright aromatics of spearmint and citrus zest." Half of that holds up superbly — spearmint is the best-corroborated claim about this whiskey. The citrus zest does not. Only two of nine reviewers found any citrus on the nose, and one of those wrote directly beneath a reprinted press release. Citrus is real here, but it is a palate event, not an aroma.
More interesting is what the brand leaves out. Dill appears nowhere in Penelope's marketing, yet three independent reviewers plus a retailer customer put it squarely on the nose. For a rye that otherwise reads as approachable and mixer-friendly, that classic dill-and-mint signature is arguably its most distinctive feature.
Our Verdict
A well-priced, herbal, mint-forward rye that does the everyday job well and does not pretend to more. The critics who liked it liked it for value and drinkability; those who didn't wanted more weight and more wood. At $35 that trade is an easy one to accept — just do not expect depth.
Community Tasting Notes
Top Reported Flavors
Typical Spread of Opinion
Illustrative shape derived from the average and the range of scores — not a published per-star breakdown.
🎁 Whiskey Review Rewards
$10 Gift Voucher — Every Review
Write a real tasting review and we'll send you a $10 digital gift voucher for barware and whiskey accessories on the store. Your honest notes help fellow rye lovers discover new favorites.
"At RyeCentral, we never pay for positive reviews — honest, unbiased opinions matter."
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Distinctive spearmint-and-dill herbal character — the best-corroborated thing about it
- 93% rye mash bill and distillery both disclosed; no mystery sourcing
- Genuinely easy at 92 proof — no reviewer reports burn or harshness
- Around $35 for a high-rye straight rye is a competitive everyday price
Cons
- Oak is near-absent — six of nine reviewers found no wood on the palate
- Mouthfeel divides reviewers sharply, from "thin and slick" to "amazing"
- No age statement, and the widely-repeated "7–9 years" retailer claim is unconfirmed
- Critics converge on competent rather than memorable
Frequently Asked Questions
❓ Who makes Penelope Straight Rye?
❓ What's the mash bill and proof?
❓ How old is it?
❓ Is it spicy?
❓ How is it different from Penelope Toasted Rye?
❓ Where can I buy Penelope Straight Rye online?
❓ How much does Penelope Straight Rye cost?
Quality You Can Trust
RyeCentral Lab
Tasted it? Get ranked for it.
Every review earns Lab points — climb the ladder from All Rye to Rye Legend. Your first review earns 100 points and $10 store credit — five stars or one.